Reporting & Analysis

Resolving Low-Performance Campaigns on Pinterest

Pinterest has become a powerhouse platform for brands and marketers alike, offering visually compelling opportunities to reach and engage audiences. However, despite the potential for success, some campaigns may face challenges that result in underwhelming performance. This article will explore how to diagnose these performance issues and provide actionable tips to turn around low-performance campaigns into successful ones.

Diagnosing performance issues

The first step in resolving low-performance campaigns on Pinterest is to thoroughly diagnose the issues contributing to their lackluster results. Understanding the root cause of the problem is crucial for making informed adjustments. Here are some common areas to evaluate:

Section Image
  • Target Audience: Assess whether your audience targeting aligns with your campaign goals. Are you reaching the right demographics and interests related to your product?
  • Ad Creative: Analyze the visual and textual elements of your ads. Do they capture attention and clearly convey the benefits of your product or service?
  • Pinterest SEO: Investigate how your content ranks within Pinterest search results. Are your keywords optimized for search visibility?
  • Engagement Metrics: Review your click-through rates (CTR) and engagement levels. Are users interacting with your pins, or are they simply scrolling past them?

By dissecting these elements, you can gain insights into potential weaknesses in your campaigns. For instance, if your ads are not resonating with your intended audience, consider revisiting your audience segments and their interests. Similarly, analyzing the visual appeal of your ads can reveal whether your imagery and messaging needs enhancement.

After a thorough evaluation, you’ll be better positioned to make strategic decisions that address the identified issues. Remember, diagnosing performance issues is not a one-time task but an ongoing process as trends and audience preferences evolve. Additionally, consider the seasonal trends that may affect user behavior on Pinterest. For example, certain products may see spikes in interest during holidays or specific events, which can significantly impact performance metrics. By aligning your campaigns with these trends, you can capitalize on heightened engagement opportunities.

Moreover, it’s essential to stay updated with Pinterest's algorithm changes and advertising features. The platform frequently rolls out new tools and updates that can enhance your campaign's effectiveness. Engaging with Pinterest's community and exploring case studies can provide valuable insights into successful strategies employed by others in your industry. By fostering a proactive approach to learning and adapting, you can ensure your campaigns remain competitive and relevant in a dynamic digital landscape.

Tips for improving ad results

Once performance issues have been diagnosed, it's time to implement targeted strategies to enhance your campaign's effectiveness. Here are several proven tips for improving ad results on Pinterest:

  1. Update Ad Creative: Refreshing your visuals can significantly impact engagement. Use high-quality images, cohesive colors, and bold typography that reflects your brand. Incorporate lifestyle shots to help your audience visualize the product in use.
  2. Utilize Rich Pins: Rich Pins automatically sync information from your website to your Pins. This feature enhances your content's context, providing users with valuable details directly on Pinterest.
  3. Experiment with Pin Formats: Try different Pin formats, such as video Pins, carousel Pins, or collection Pins. These formats can provide variety and a more interactive experience for users, which may lead to higher engagement rates.
  4. Refine Targeting: Use Pinterest’s targeting options to hone in on specific audience segments. Refine age, gender, interests, and behaviors to ensure you are reaching the most relevant users for your campaigns.
  5. A/B Testing: Conduct A/B tests to compare different elements of your ads, such as visuals, headlines, and call-to-action buttons. Analyzing the performance of these variations can help identify the most effective combinations.

Implementing these tips requires careful planning and execution. As you introduce changes to your campaign, keep detailed records of performance metrics to assess the impact of the adjustments. This methodical approach will help identify what works best for your brand on Pinterest.

Additionally, consider the timing of your ads. Seasonal trends and events can greatly influence user behavior on Pinterest. For instance, promoting holiday-themed products well in advance of the season can capture the interest of users who are already planning their celebrations. Similarly, aligning your ad campaigns with popular trends or Pinterest searches can enhance visibility and engagement.

Moreover, engaging with your audience can further amplify your ad results. Encourage users to save your Pins and interact with your content by asking questions or prompting discussions in your Pin descriptions. Building a community around your brand not only fosters loyalty but also encourages organic sharing, which can lead to increased reach and visibility for your ads.

Examples of successful turnarounds

Real-world examples of successful turnarounds provide inspiration and insight into effective strategies for improving Pinterest ad campaigns. Here are two case studies that highlight the effectiveness of strategic shifts in campaign management:

Section Image

Case Study 1: Home Décor Brand

A home décor brand was struggling with a low click-through rate on its Pinterest ads. After analyzing their audience targeting and ad creative, they discovered that the imagery used did not resonate with their desired demographic. The brand decided to update their visuals to feature more aspirational lifestyle shots that portrayed their products being used in beautifully decorated homes.

Additionally, they employed A/B testing with different headlines and incorporated rich pins to enhance engagement. As a result, the brand experienced a significant boost in CTR, leading to a 50% increase in purchases attributed to their Pinterest ads. They also leveraged user-generated content, encouraging customers to share photos of their purchases in their own homes, which not only provided authentic content but also fostered a sense of community around the brand. This strategy not only improved engagement but also built trust among potential customers, showcasing real-life applications of their products.

Case Study 2: Fashion Retailer

A fashion retailer faced challenges with poor engagement metrics. In their evaluation, they realized that their targeting parameters were too broad, leading to wasted ad spend on uninterested users. They refined their audience by focusing on users who had demonstrated interest in similar brands and items.

Furthermore, they introduced video Pins showcasing outfits styled in different ways, which resulted in higher engagement. By monitoring their performance closely, they adapted their strategy over time, ultimately doubling their engagement rate and achieving a notable increase in website traffic from Pinterest. In addition to video content, they began to create seasonal lookbooks that highlighted trending styles and seasonal collections, allowing users to visualize how to incorporate their pieces into their wardrobes. This not only kept their content fresh but also positioned the brand as a go-to source for fashion inspiration, further enhancing their visibility on the platform.

These case studies demonstrate that with systematic diagnosis, tailored strategies, and creativity, brands can resolve low-performance campaigns on Pinterest and achieve their marketing goals. By continuously learning from results and adjusting as necessary, marketers can harness the full potential of the platform. The importance of data analytics cannot be overstated; brands that invest time in understanding user behavior and preferences are better equipped to create compelling content that resonates with their audience.

In conclusion, understanding the intricacies of Pinterest campaigns and being willing to adapt will pave the way for success. Whether through diagnosing performance issues, implementing effective strategies, or drawing inspiration from successful case studies, marketers have the tools they need to turn low-performance campaigns into powerful marketing assets.

Author
Matteo Braghetta
Google Ads Specialist, SEM Specialist, Founder.

As a Google Ads expert, I bring proven expertise in optimizing advertising campaigns to maximize ROI.

I specialize in sharing advanced strategies and targeted tips to refine Google Ads campaign management.
Committed to staying ahead of the latest trends and algorithms, I ensure that my clients receive cutting-edge solutions.

My passion for digital marketing and my ability to interpret data for strategic insights enable me to offer high-level consulting that aims to exceed expectations.

Google Partner Agency

We're a certified Google Partner Agency, which means we don’t guess — we optimize withGoogle’s full toolkit and insider support.
Your campaigns get pro-level execution, backed by real expertise (not theory).

Start a project
Google Partner logo
Testimonial

4.9 out of 5 from 670+ reviews on Fiverr.
That’s not luck — that’s performance.

Highly recommend Matteo to set up your server side tracking. He has a deep understanding of e-commerce tracking and will go above and beyond to make sure everything is set up correctly and working 100%. If you are scaling your store this set up is non-negotiable in my opinion and there isn't many people who have this much knowledge or put the effort in to get it right. Thanks again!

Avoro Design
avorodesign.com

I can only recommend Matteo! He was very patient, professional and very knowledgeable about GA4, Consent Mode v2, and GDPR compliance. Communication was clear, and the setup was done professionally and efficiently. Highly recommend him for anyone needing reliable tracking implementation.

Natureiki
www.natureiki.life

Matteo shines in the realm of online professionals. His work is not only deep in data but also complemented by his proactive communication and cooperation, setting a new standard for freelancers. If you want someone who truly exceeds expectations, look no further. Highly recommended!

Oman Beverly Smyth
www.omanbeverlysmyth.com

Exceptional Service Beyond Expectations - Outstanding Service Impeccable depth, flawless delivery, and exceptional language fluency—this service exceeded all expectations. Highly recommended. Matteo truly ROCKS!!!

IUM Paris
ium-paris.com

Top-notch, always highly value working with Matteo. An absolute Google Ads Genius. This is approximately the 8th time I have hired him and he's helped us get 6-7 ROAS. We are excited in continuing to improve our lead flow. Hire this guy if you need Google Ads help. Thanks Matteo!

DLE Event Group
www.dleeventgroup.com

I finally found the guy who can setup server side tracking and all the ecosystem properly. I definitely recommend Matteo. He is very responsive, kind and wants to dig into things. He configured GA4, Meta, Google Ads, Outbrain and google consent v2 with Cookiebot. Thanks Matteo.

Inomega
inomega.fr

MB Adv delivered exceptional work with outstanding professionalism and lots of patience, taking time to see effects of changes made and not just do the work and submit it. The proactive communication and video summaries of the work completed made working with Matteo a pleasure, as he consistently went above and beyond. Highly recommended for web analytics projects! We are already working on another project.

Withnell Sensors
www.withnellsensors.co.uk

Working with Matteo on my Google Ads was a game-changer. He's not just a strategist, he's a true partner. He understood my goals and tailored a campaign that perfectly reached my target audience. I'm grateful for his expertise and dedication.

DC Cargo
dccargo.com
Know us

Click-driven mind
with plastic-brick obsession.

We build Google Ads campaigns with the same mindset we use to build tiny brick worlds: strategy, patience, and zero tolerance for wasted pieces.
Data is our blueprint. Growth is the only acceptable outcome.

Start a project
Focused digital strategist assembling plastic bricks on a table, next to a Google Partner mug — symbolizing precision, patience, and performance-driven PPC mindset